Confiscating phones 'problematic' in class

Although canton Vaud has a rule of no cell phones in the classroom – teachers say the punishment of confiscating them is becoming highly problematic as the phone serves many uses.

Some schools will take a phone away for 24 hours for the first offence – but the confiscation time could be as much as a week for several violations. 

But phones today are not just phones, they’re also public transport travel cards, payment systems and parents use them to track their children. A feature they want and value, so they don’t want their children to be separated from them.

Last month a court in Fribourg backed a father whose child had had his phone confiscated for a week. The father, who doesn’t live his child, says not being able to communicate with them for a week is unreasonable. 

A judge agreed and called the lengthy ban ‘unreasonable’. 

The court referred to rules in some German speaking cantons, such as Zurich, Solothurn and Basel-Country, that state the phone can only be seized during the school day and for a maximum of half a day. 

More from Bitesize News

  • Lake Geneva steamships at risk

    A majority of National Councillors want the Confederation to step in to rescue Lake Geneva's historic steamships

  • Lausanne prison overcrowding meeting

    A new forum in Lausanne drew more than 500 people over the weekend to debate the Lake Geneva region's record prison overcrowding

  • New motorway faces opposition

    Geneva and five neighbouring communes have filed legal challenges against the A412 motorway in Haute-Savoie, fearing a flood of extra traffic through Rive gauche villages once the road opens

  • Process underway to find new Swiss President

    Guy Parmelin's successor on the Federal Council must be chosen by December, with the UDC under pressure to put forward a woman for only the second time in a quarter-century

  • Weekend Geneva protest

    Around 1,500 people marched through Geneva on Saturday to demand Switzerland impose sanctions on Israel, three years after the 7 October attacks that triggered the Gaza war

  • New app launch in Neuchâtel

    La Chaux-de-Fonds is testing a resident-only 'super-app' built on top of its local currency

Download our app

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play