We're not responsible for comments by others on our newsfeeds

Pixabay

We are not responsible for what people may post on our own social media news feeds.

That’s a ruling from the Federal Court. 

Judges were hearing a test case involving a former member of the Swiss Peoples Party, Yvan Perrin. 

He posted a comment about Muslims in 2019. That particular comment was not deemed illegal. But it attracted several offensive comments from readers. 

Prosecutors in canton Neuchatel argued that it was Perrin’s responsibility to delete the comments as they were on his news feed. Perrin claims he was unaware of the racist posts. 

The Federal Court, upholding rulings from two lower courts, rejected the argument. 

The judges say it would be possible to take action if known posts were left available – but social media users are not obliged to monitor all reactions.

The court said that would be an unreasonable and permanent duty of care. 

Perrin welcomed the ruling – calling it a victory for free speech. 

More from Bitesize News

  • Geneva could foot the G7 bill

    Geneva fears it will be left with the security bill from a G7 summit just across the border in Évian, according to 24 heures.

  • US NGO discovers Swiss child abuse cases

    Switzerland relies too heavily on an American NGO to detect child sexual abuse online, raising questions about the country's ability to protect children on its own.

  • French singer banned by Paleo

    The Paléo Festival in Nyon says it will no longer invite French singer Patrick Bruel, after a former volunteer accused him of inappropriate behaviour.

  • Cars going uninspected

    The cantons are struggling to keep up with mandatory vehicle inspections, leaving more than 550,000 checks overdue nationwide.

  • War may lead to rent rises

    Rents may rise again, says the bank Raiffeisen.

  • Not a heatwave, yet

    Summer has arrived, with temperatures climbing past 30 over the long weekend. Basel reached 31 and Sion hit 32.4, but MeteoSwiss, says this does not yet count as an official heatwave.

Download our app

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play